Lobbyists are writing the legislation!
What’s that you say? You already knew?
Apparently the health care “reform bill” from the House of Representatives is loaded with industry written components. One item from the Republican reform proposal that was added to House bill word-for-word, was originally written by Big Pharma. It gives them virtually unlimited patent rights on life-saving drugs, which then gives them the right to set the prices at outrageous levels – as high as $400,000 per year for some.
Passed without question.
A Genentech spokesperson defended it by saying this happens all the time, as we have been telling you on this blog. Does that make it OK?
We know the talking points were cleverly crafted by the paid talent of the health care industry, then parroted by the Democratic Representatives who signed on. A casual comparative reading of some of the politicans’ statements shows word-for-word copycatting.
How many other items in that bill were written by industry with the effect of handing over tax dollars in perpetuity?
Here’s the worst case scenario: the truth about this comes out in small town papers and blogs on both sides, the implications for future health care costs are calculated, and the possibility of health care reform goes down the drain.
No wait, it could be worse. The public option bites the dust (because that’s the single biggest government component of the bill) but the rest of the bill – the parts written by those who will profit from them - gets approved and signed by the President. We the people end up being forced to buy health insurance from a few select providers, and there are no controls on the cost of the services and products, jacking up the health care profitability even beyond the unacceptable levels we face now.
The best case: the truth about this comes out in small town papers and blogs on both sides, the implications for future health care costs are calculated, and the people demand that all those pig trough amendments be dropped, we keep the strong public option and then give that government plan the right to negotiate prices for services and products. True competition erupts, everyone is covered and over time, we pare down the relative costs, giving us back money for education, highways, and pay raises!
Which do you think is likely?
Unless the people stand up and demand responsible legislative behavior, I fear the worst of the worst. Lobbyists own Congress. Is there a majority of representatives and senators who will stand up to the health care industry pressure and do the right thing? I submit that will only happen if the people, literally, take to the streets, flood the mailrooms, crash the email servers, and clog up the phone lines.
Get busy!
* * * * * * * * * * * *
We’ve been “off the air” of the blog-o-sphere for the past couple of weeks, sitting back and watching things develop. Couldn’t keep our mouths shut forever, though. Keep watching… there’s more to come.
JM
Showing posts with label health industry lobby. Show all posts
Showing posts with label health industry lobby. Show all posts
Monday, November 16, 2009
Tuesday, September 22, 2009
Playing To Win: Why the GOP almost always gets what they want!
Don’t you sometimes wish that more Congressional Democrats would somehow find their spines? Wouldn’t you love to see them wield that big stick like the Republicans did during the eight years of W’s administration?
Hell, the GOP still carried on like the cock of the walk even after they lost control of the House and Senate following the 2006 midterms! They regarded the Democrats as more of a nuisance to be ignored than any kind of real obstruction…and they basically continued doing whatever they wanted to do…right up until they lost control of everything in November of 2008.
Even that hasn’t stopped them because except for the White House, they’re still controlling the show in Washington. The GOP has framed the Health Care Reform debate since the outset with one outrageous claim after another…putting the Dems consistently on the defensive. Death Panels, rationed care, socialized medicine, covering illegal immigrants, Medicare cuts…the Republicans, their activist organizations and their media shills throw whatever they can think of at the wall, knowing full well that even though it’s all bullshit, some of it will stick and all of it leaves a stain and a stink that never quite goes away.
In short, they play the game however they have to in order to achieve their goals. When they were in power, the Republican objective was to craft virtually every single piece of legislation and tailor every other decision in such a way that it would benefit big business and the wealthiest Americans. And now that they’re not in power, at least not in theory, their sole objective is to stop the Democrats at every turn.
They succeeded wildly then, and they’re succeeding wildly now…and it would seem that the Dems, at least insofar as they’re currently constituted, are not capable of winning this game. With far too few exceptions they just don’t appear to have the stomach for the fight. So once again the GOP is controlling the show, and that my friends is a sad commentary on the people we sent to Washington to bring about ‘change we could believe in’.
Look at the evidence! Every time someone speaking for the Dems stands up to be counted by speaking his or her mind on an issue, they end up being villainized by the right wing and that’s the story the mainstream media runs with. Worse yet, no one on the left comes to their defense. But every time a Republican stands up, even someone like South Carolina Congressman Joe Wilson who’s only claim to fame was acting like an unprincipled idiot, they end up being lionized by the right wing…and guess what story the mainstream media runs with in that instance?
The real tragedy in all of this is that for the first time in our history the stars all seemed to be aligned for meaningful Health Care Reform, but the Democrats look as if they can’t, or won’t, carry the ball across the goal line. On the surface, the reasons might seem complicated…but they’re really not. Simply put, too many Democrats are more afraid of losing the financial support they receive from the health industry lobby than they are concerned about losing the support of their electorate. Apparently money talks louder than votes.
We may yet end up with some sort of a Health Care bill being passed into law, but it’s looking less likely every day that it will contain any meaningful reform…that it will have the teeth to bring the health insurance industry to heel. We sincerely hope we’re wrong… but as of right now it just doesn’t look very promising. The Republicans are still being allowed to wield their big stick even though the Democrats have the power of numbers on their side. But the numbers don’t mean jack if the Dems aren’t willing to use this advantage as their hammer. That’s what the GOP would do!
When are we ever going to learn? If it’s worthwhile playing the game, it’s worthwhile playing to win. Carpe diem Democrats…Carpe diem.
SC
Hell, the GOP still carried on like the cock of the walk even after they lost control of the House and Senate following the 2006 midterms! They regarded the Democrats as more of a nuisance to be ignored than any kind of real obstruction…and they basically continued doing whatever they wanted to do…right up until they lost control of everything in November of 2008.
Even that hasn’t stopped them because except for the White House, they’re still controlling the show in Washington. The GOP has framed the Health Care Reform debate since the outset with one outrageous claim after another…putting the Dems consistently on the defensive. Death Panels, rationed care, socialized medicine, covering illegal immigrants, Medicare cuts…the Republicans, their activist organizations and their media shills throw whatever they can think of at the wall, knowing full well that even though it’s all bullshit, some of it will stick and all of it leaves a stain and a stink that never quite goes away.
In short, they play the game however they have to in order to achieve their goals. When they were in power, the Republican objective was to craft virtually every single piece of legislation and tailor every other decision in such a way that it would benefit big business and the wealthiest Americans. And now that they’re not in power, at least not in theory, their sole objective is to stop the Democrats at every turn.
They succeeded wildly then, and they’re succeeding wildly now…and it would seem that the Dems, at least insofar as they’re currently constituted, are not capable of winning this game. With far too few exceptions they just don’t appear to have the stomach for the fight. So once again the GOP is controlling the show, and that my friends is a sad commentary on the people we sent to Washington to bring about ‘change we could believe in’.
Look at the evidence! Every time someone speaking for the Dems stands up to be counted by speaking his or her mind on an issue, they end up being villainized by the right wing and that’s the story the mainstream media runs with. Worse yet, no one on the left comes to their defense. But every time a Republican stands up, even someone like South Carolina Congressman Joe Wilson who’s only claim to fame was acting like an unprincipled idiot, they end up being lionized by the right wing…and guess what story the mainstream media runs with in that instance?
The real tragedy in all of this is that for the first time in our history the stars all seemed to be aligned for meaningful Health Care Reform, but the Democrats look as if they can’t, or won’t, carry the ball across the goal line. On the surface, the reasons might seem complicated…but they’re really not. Simply put, too many Democrats are more afraid of losing the financial support they receive from the health industry lobby than they are concerned about losing the support of their electorate. Apparently money talks louder than votes.
We may yet end up with some sort of a Health Care bill being passed into law, but it’s looking less likely every day that it will contain any meaningful reform…that it will have the teeth to bring the health insurance industry to heel. We sincerely hope we’re wrong… but as of right now it just doesn’t look very promising. The Republicans are still being allowed to wield their big stick even though the Democrats have the power of numbers on their side. But the numbers don’t mean jack if the Dems aren’t willing to use this advantage as their hammer. That’s what the GOP would do!
When are we ever going to learn? If it’s worthwhile playing the game, it’s worthwhile playing to win. Carpe diem Democrats…Carpe diem.
SC
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)